Explore
Gaia Soulmates
 Advertising keeps Gaia free! Interested in sponsoring us?

Social Justice in an Attention Economy

Posted on Jul 12th, 2007 by P'SAL : Graphic Designer, etc. P'SAL
Picture_17
The latest Paris Hilton hysteria has got me thinking: are we being robbed? With the media so focused on the blonde-tressed heiress's inane flounderings through the Los Angeles penal system, aren't there a whole lot more important topics -- ahem, Net Neutrality -- we should be focusing on? With everyone's attention made increasingly scarce by increased workloads, the proliferation of TV channels, and the latest web 2.0 app-of-the-minute, who's NOT getting attention? What about the old, the sick, the elderly, the brilliant, and the necessary? Redistribution of wealth has long been a concern of social justice movements past and present. But their focus has traditionally been on material wealth, not attention wealth. Without seeking to minimize this very real concern (people still starve in America, FYI), what would it mean to give people a fighting chance in an economy increasingly focused on one's ability to capture, keep, and redirect attention from others? Is it only the stars who will survive? Hilton's family may hog a lot of financial wealth, but she herself is guilty of attention greed. And it is people like she who must be fought should the lore-filled grandmas, mute starving children, and good-hearted scientists of the world get a chance in a spotlight. But how do you fight for justice in an attention economy? For one: make the uninteresting and obscure accessible and fascination. Find ways to reframe things currently perceived as "boring" or "lame" using marketing techniques, design, copy writing, web apps like YouTube, and other tricks of the purple cow trade. More importantly: help those who are struggling to get noticed find in themselves what actually is WORTH noticing, why the world needs it, and how it can be made more public. This past winter marked the passing of my last remaining grandparent, my maternal grandfather Joe. As with all of my previous grandparents, what I regretted most with his passing -- along with missing his voice, face, and presence -- was all of the knowledge and experience he contained within his slender frame, knowledge which could/should have been better captured for the benefit of all of us. While he was by no means unnoticed (in fact, he was a pillar of his local community), he certainly had more to share that could benefit humanity than an attention hog like Hilton. (Interestingly, he himself was a staunch advocate of social justice.) So now, with the Grandpa Joes of the world fading away and Parisian idiocracy holding sway, what will a new movement for equality, fairness, and most of all, compassion, look like in an Attention Economy? How will it sound? Where will it appear? But most of all: who will notice it? Us, I hope.
Access_public Access: Public 3 Comments Print views (2,679)  
Casey : Conscious Marketer
about 17 hours later
Casey said

Brilliant distinction Paul. Brilliant.

In my brief stint working in television i noticed, and was increasingly dismayed by what I affectionately labeled “LCD entertainment.” Power is built on appeals to the Lowest-Common-Denominator. Paris Hilton rigorously strums a few of the lowest chakras, but never manages to harmonize at the heart or higher. Another way to put this would be that she appeals to lower-order maslow needs, sex, and power. These lower-order needs are shared by most all humans and thus the appeal is nearly universal. She is a force of span,,, depth in question.

Given unlimited choice, everyone can find something to notice about the wayward princess, but may find disinterest or challenge in content coming from higher values. When we look for entertainment, we often don’t want a challenge. If power in the attention economy comes from the numbers of audience(votes) then the LCD Entertainment will ALWAYS win out over serious, in depth, rigorous content. This may very well be the shadow of democratization.

I don’t have a solution here, except that each of us should learn to honor expertise, wisdom, and brilliance everywhere we encounter it, and do our best to give it a lift in the game for relevance.

I tip my hat to you sir, my attention is yours anytime.

P'SAL : Graphic Designer, etc.
about 22 hours later
P'SAL said

@casey: excellent, re: sex and power. It reminds me of classic Greek mythology, actually, which if you actually read it, isn’t all that deep, but it IS entertaining, and thus it has spread. Ms. Hilton is like one of the amoral, self-obsessed denizens of Mount Olympus, touching our world only when it suits her whimsy.

Either way, I’m sad that LCD will “always win”, but I also think this strengthens my resolve to fight for expertise, wisdom, and brilliance… not to mention spread love to those who find it in short supply.

Hat tipped back.

Duff : Modern Magician
about 23 hours later
Duff said

Another way of coping is to practice abstracting depth from shallowness, as you have displayed here in this blog post (from Paris to Compassion). It's tricky though, because you can easily get sucked into the shallows.

You have to be a Gaia member to post comments.
Login or Join now!